Chef holding a freshly baked D'Agostino's pizza with meatballs, fresh tomatoes, and herbs
Guests sharing a large D'Agostino's pizza around the table

Handcrafted Since 1955

Our Pizza

Since 1955, our family has believed that great pizza brings people together. Whether you're gathering around a table in our restaurant or carrying a hot pizza home, there's something special about opening the box, sharing the first slice, and making memories with the people you love. Every pizza is created by our chefs, handcrafted by our pizzaiolos, and baked fresh to order. We hope your family's next pizza tradition begins here.

Signature Pizzas

Prices shown as 10" · 14" · 16"

Mozzarella cheese pull on a D'Agostino's pizza — white plate, light background
Chop Chop SupremeHouse Favorite

Created by our chefs and handcrafted by our pizzaiolos, the Chop Chop Supreme is layered with Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, fresh garlic, mushrooms, red onion, and fresh basil, then finished with our house Italian dressing and a light balsamic drizzle. One bite and you'll understand why it's one of our house favorites.

$19 | $25 | $30

Chop Chop Supreme pizza — Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, and fresh basil
Margherita

Fresh mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, fragrant basil, and extra virgin olive oil come together in a timeless Italian classic inspired by the pizza created for Queen Margherita of Italy. If it was good enough for a queen, we think you'll love it too.

$16 | $21 | $26

Margherita pizza — fresh mozzarella, vine-ripened tomatoes, and fragrant basil
Quattro Formaggio

Four exceptional cheeses come together without red sauce, creating a rich, creamy pizza that lets every cheese shine. Featuring mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan, and Gorgonzola, sometimes the simplest recipes are the most unforgettable.

$16 | $23 | $26

Quattro Formaggio pizza — four cheeses, no red sauce
The Zoo

Inspired by the original Navajo Trading Post & Zoo that welcomed travelers to Bridgman for generations, this crowd favorite is loaded with Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, fresh garlic, and banana peppers. A tribute to a piece of local history that's still bringing people together.

$17 | $23 | $28

The Zoo pizza — Italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, and banana peppers
The Big Dill

Some pizzas play it safe. This one doesn't. Our signature ranch and pickle-brine sauce is topped with dill pickle slices, crispy bacon, and red onion to create a bold favorite that's earned a loyal following among pickle lovers.

$16 | $20 | $24

The Big Dill pizza — ranch pickle-brine sauce, dill pickles, crispy bacon, red onion
The Trifecta

There's a method to our pepperoni madness. We layer deli-style, classic, and cup-and-char pepperoni because each brings its own flavor, texture, and character to the pizza. Finished with mozzarella, Gorgonzola, Asiago, and a drizzle of hot honey, every bite is a little different—and every one is delicious.

$17 | $23 | $28

The Trifecta pizza — three pepperoni styles, Gorgonzola, Asiago, and hot honey
Spicy Hawaiian

Sweet meets just the right touch of warmth in this island-inspired favorite. Capicola, ham, juicy pineapple, Sweet Drop Peppadew peppers, and a drizzle of hot honey come together to create the perfect balance of sweet, smoky, savory, and just enough spice to keep you coming back for another bite.

$17 | $23 | $28

Spicy Hawaiian pizza — capicola, ham, pineapple, Sweet Drop Peppadew peppers, and hot honey
BBQ Chicken

Slow down and enjoy this backyard favorite. We start with our tangy barbecue sauce, then layer on tender chicken, crispy bacon, red onion, and a blend of Colby Jack and mozzarella for the perfect sweet, smoky, and savory bite.

$16 | $21 | $27

BBQ Chicken pizza — barbecue sauce, chicken, bacon, red onion, Colby Jack and mozzarella
Classic Combo

Every family has a favorite pizza, and for generations this has been ours. Italian sausage, green peppers, and mushrooms create the classic combination that has brought families together around the dinner table for decades. Sometimes the classics become classics for a reason.

$15 | $20 | $25

Classic Combo pizza — Italian sausage, green peppers, and mushrooms

Choose Your Size

10"SinglelottaPersonal$13
14"MediumServes 2–3$16
16"LargeServes 3–4$19

Build Your Own

Each extra topping: 10" +$1 · Med +$1.75 · Lg +$2.25

Premium toppings: 10" +$2 · Med +$4 · Lg +$6

Sauce / Base

House Pizza SauceMarinara (dairy free)AlfredoEVOOBBQ (+$2)Pesto (+$3)

Vegetables & Fruits

Banana PeppersBasilBlack OlivesGreen PepperJalapeñoMinced GarlicMushroomsPepperonciniPineappleRed OnionSpinachTomatoWhite Onion

Meat

BaconCapicolaGround BeefHamItalian SausageMeatballPepperoniSalami

Premium Toppings

AnchoviesArtichokesChickenFennel SausageMixed Bell PeppersProsciuttoRoast BeefShrimpWild Mushrooms
  • Gluten-free crust available on 10" only — add $3.
  • Available for dine-in and carryout Tuesday–Saturday.
  • Stop by after a day at Warren Dunes or Weko Beach.

Order by Phone

Call ahead for carryout or to check on wait times. We'll have your pizza ready when you arrive.